In short
A bug bounty is a program through which an organization invites security researchers to search for vulnerabilities within a defined scope and pays them for each valid vulnerability reported. It differs from a vulnerability disclosure policy (VDP), which governs reports without a reward, and from a penetration test, which methodically covers a scope within a set timeframe. A bug bounty program requires a certain level of maturity: the ability to quickly triage, fix, and reward.
Bug Bounty, VDP, and Penetration Testing
| Vulnerability Disclosure Policy (VDP) | Bug bounty | Penetration test | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compensation | None, sometimes public recognition | A reward per valid vulnerability | A service with a defined scope |
| Coverage | What researchers report on their own initiative | What interests researchers | Methodical, across the entire agreed-upon scope |
| Timeline | Ongoing | Ongoing or time-limited | Defined timeframe, dated report |
| Evidence for an audit or a client | Low | Partial | Actionable Report |
Prerequisites
- Clear scope and rules: what is permitted, what is excluded, and how to report.
- A security.txt file (RFC 9116) that specifies where to report a vulnerability.
- A team capable of sorting through numerous reports of varying quality and then fixing them quickly.
- Obvious vulnerabilities must already have been addressed; otherwise, the program ends up paying for discoveries one by one that an audit would have identified all at once.
The Legal Framework in France
A bug bounty program covers only the scope and rules established by the organization: testing a system outside this framework may constitute unauthorized access under Article 323-1 of the French Criminal Code. Furthermore, Article L. 2321-4 of the Defense Code allows a person acting in good faith to report a vulnerability exclusively to ANSSI, which preserves the confidentiality of the reporter’s identity.
Frequently asked questions
Bug bounty or penetration test: where to start?
This is typically done through a penetration test, which methodically covers the scope and eliminates obvious vulnerabilities. The bug bounty program then comes next, as a complementary measure, to benefit from the diversity of researchers over the long term.
Sources
Find out where an attacker would get in.
Our AI agents actually attack your scope, fully automated, and hand you the proof of every vulnerability.
